By Gav & Em · How to English TEFL Podcast
Short answer: Check whether the contribution serves the lesson and includes the rest of the group. If it does, give it a clear purpose and a short turn. If it cuts someone off, excludes others or takes the class away from its aim, pause it politely and explain what will happen next.
Try this in your next lesson
Use a calm boundary: ‘That looks relevant. Let me finish this example, then you can show us for one minute. Everyone else, listen for one similarity and one difference.’ Adjust the task to your learners’ language and the lesson aim.
Does taking control mean the lesson has gone wrong?
Not necessarily. A learner may be eager to contribute something directly connected to the task. The useful question is what the contribution does for the class. Does it create meaningful English use and invite other learners in, or does it replace a shared task with one person’s presentation?
In S07E21, Em describes showing a tradition from her own country when a learner begins sharing their screen. The class was meant to exchange traditions, so the contribution fitted the overall goal. Em’s concern was the timing: she had not finished her point and was surprised to lose control of the screen.
Gav asks whether it is a group lesson, whether the others will be interested and whether the target language is being used. He is happy to follow the learner’s contribution when everyone can take part. Em comes to see the enthusiasm as something positive. That judgement still leaves room to manage the handover respectfully.
What should you check in the moment?
First, check relevance. A photograph of a local celebration may support a lesson about traditions; a long unrelated video may need to wait. Second, check access: can the other learners see, understand and respond? Third, check the language opportunity: what will everyone do with what is being shown?
A relevant contribution can still need support. A learner may have a fascinating picture but lack the language to explain it. Offer a short frame: ‘This happens in … People usually … In this picture, they are …’ Give the others one manageable question rather than expecting a spontaneous discussion to happen automatically.
Check who is participating after the first few exchanges. Interest from one confident learner does not establish that the whole group is involved. You may need a quiet thinking moment, pair preparation or a turn for someone who has not spoken. The teacher’s role continues even when a learner supplies the material.
How can you welcome the idea and set a boundary?
Acknowledge the connection, then manage the timing: ‘That’s a good example for this topic. I’ll finish this sentence, then we’ll look at yours.’ This protects the current speaker and makes it clear that the learner’s contribution has a place.
If several people want to share, agree an order and a brief turn for each. Ask contributors to explain one detail and answer one question. Invite classmates to compare rather than simply watch. A time limit is useful when it creates room for others; it does not need to be presented as a punishment for enthusiasm.
If the learner is already sharing, you can say: ‘Pause there for a moment. Let’s make sure everyone knows what we’re looking for.’ Give the group a question and let the learner continue. If the material does not fit, explain the next step: ‘Let’s save that for the final discussion. We need to finish the comparison first.’
What would a short traditions task look like?
Give the contributor a minute to show one image and explain what the tradition is, where it happens and what people do. Let them use a personal example or choose a familiar public event. Nobody needs to share private family information to contribute to the task.
Ask the rest of the group to note one detail they understood and prepare one question. For lower levels, put two question starters on the board: ‘When do people …?’ and ‘Do you usually …?’ For stronger learners, ask for a comparison and a reason for a similarity or difference.
After the questions, pairs summarise one thing they learned and compare it with another tradition they know. Listen and gather a small amount of language for feedback. Give learners a chance to improve a sentence, then return to the wider lesson. The contribution has now become a task involving the group.
For the wider planning decision, let students lead while keeping the lesson’s purpose clear. The screen-sharing routine here gives that principle a practical boundary in an online group.
What if the energy is high but the learning is disappearing?
Use the problem you can observe. If everyone is speaking at once, reset the turns. If one learner has spoken for several minutes, invite others to compare in pairs. If the discussion has moved into a shared first language and the task is English practice, supply the expressions learners need to continue in English.
Gav and Em recognise that excitement can spill over into a different language. Bring learners back to the agreed task calmly: ‘Let’s try that explanation again in English. Here are two phrases that may help.’ Check whether the original demand was manageable rather than treating every difficulty as unwillingness.
After class, consider a simple screen-sharing routine: ask before switching, explain what you want to show and wait for the handover. A clear routine can preserve the spontaneity you value while giving every speaker a fair chance to finish.
Hear Gav and Em discuss this
Listen to Gav’s three questions when Em describes a learner taking over screen-sharing, and hear how they weigh enthusiasm against everyone’s participation.
Read the clip transcript
Gav: Is it a group lesson?
Em: Yes.
Gav: Will all the other students be interested?
Em: Possibly.
Gav: Is the target language being used?
Em: Yeah.
Gav: Well, I would let that student continue, and bring all the other students in and make sure everybody’s talking about it, adding details from their own points of view.
Em: Which is what I did, and it was actually the goal of the lesson for everyone to be sharing their own traditions, but I just wasn’t quite ready, and I was a little bit surprised.
Em: You might be right then. If their enthusiasm is so effervescent that they can’t contain themselves or wait a moment longer, that they have to show you this thing, then maybe your job is done, and you can just let the language flow and give it to your students to take over.
Gav: As long as everybody’s involved, I’m really, really happy for them to take control.
Em: I’ll see it as a positive then, Gav. Thank you for that.
Gav: As long as they’re all speaking English, of course.
Teacher checklist
☐ Check relevance to the lesson aim.
☐ Protect the current speaker’s turn.
☐ Give the contribution a short, clear purpose.
☐ Set a listening or speaking task for everyone else.
☐ Use feedback and return to the lesson’s next step.
Use TE1 to keep the lesson aim visible. Write the intended learner action before class, then use it to judge whether an unexpected contribution helps the group practise.