By Gav & Em · How to English TEFL Podcast
Short answer: Choose one useful thing learners should be able to do, select enough language to support it and protect time for practice, feedback and another attempt. Add depth when learners need it and can use it. Covering more material is only helpful if they can do something with it.
Try this in your next lesson
Before your next lesson, complete: ‘By the end, learners can ___.’ Circle the practice that demonstrates this. Move one extra explanation or vocabulary set to a later lesson so there is time to try the task twice.
What does lesson overload look like?
A lesson can become crowded without containing many activities. One long explanation may introduce so many meanings, exceptions and examples that learners cannot see which part to use. Equally, a sequence of quick activities can keep everyone busy while leaving little time to practise any one thing properly.
In S07E21, Gav describes starting with a simple topic and allowing detail to emerge when students need it. Em enjoys exploring a small point in depth when learners are engaged. Their common ground is the learner: an extended discussion should produce useful language, while a concise lesson should still provide enough support and challenge.
Look for evidence during the task. Are learners trying the language with increasing independence? Can they distinguish the meanings you are teaching? Do they need more practice with the current point before another one arrives? Those observations are more useful than counting how many items you have presented.
How do you choose a useful takeaway?
Write the takeaway as an action. ‘Present perfect’ names an area of grammar; ‘Say how long you have had a job’ describes something a learner can do. You can then choose examples, prompts and feedback that support that action.
Em recalls trying to teach every aspect of the present perfect in one lesson and leaving students unclear. She contrasts that with giving time to the difference between for and since. In the episode, the examples are a duration, ‘for 20 years’, and a starting point, ‘since 2006’. The narrower focus gives the practice a clear boundary.
That does not mean a particular grammar point always needs a full lesson or a fixed amount of time. Decide from the learners’ needs and their performance. A group that already understands the distinction may need only a brief reminder before a richer task. Another group may need modelling, guided choices and several opportunities to use it.
What would a focused lesson sequence look like?
For an A2–B1 group who already know some present perfect, choose the goal ‘Ask and answer how long a situation has continued.’ Start with two meaningful models: ‘I’ve worked here for three years’ and ‘I’ve lived here since 2022.’ Check duration and starting point, then let learners supply examples that are true for them or for an invented character.
Pairs prepare three questions about a job, home or hobby. They interview each other and note the answers. Listen for the target distinction and whether the answer matches the question. Keep unrelated grammar questions on a short list for later if answering them would interrupt the practice everyone currently needs.
After the first round, give focused feedback. Ask learners to correct or improve one answer, then change partners and try again with a new question. Finish by asking each learner for one accurate example and a brief explanation of their choice. That final response tells you more than asking whether everyone understands.
For a B1 group, HL1: How long has it been? supplies duration questions and for/since practice. Select those stages for this lesson and save the other present-perfect work for another day.
Can a simple topic still lead to a deep lesson?
Yes. Em describes conversations that grew from apparently small details, including a bicycle saddle. The original topic may be simple, while the explanation, comparison or personal story creates substantial language work. The important question is whether learners are interested and have something to communicate.
Gav adds a useful teacher check: are you pursuing the topic because you find it fascinating, or because the learner is getting something from it? In a one-to-one lesson you can ask directly: ‘Would you like to explore this further, or move on?’ In a group, check that more than the keenest person can contribute.
If the discussion produces a useful question, follow it far enough to meet the need. If it becomes a specialist monologue or learners run out of interest, close it and return to the task. Flexibility works best when you can still identify the learning opportunity.
If a learner already feels overwhelmed, reduce the immediate demand and agree one manageable next step before adding another explanation.
How much vocabulary should you include?
Gav and Em use phrasal verbs with take to illustrate the risk of presenting a large list at once. Em suggests a small selection of genuinely useful phrases. Treat the number as a planning judgement, rather than a universal limit for every learner or lesson.
Choose phrases that belong to the task and give learners a reason to retrieve them. Three expressions used in a realistic exchange, revisited after feedback and recalled next lesson may be a better choice for this class than a longer list with one matching exercise. More advanced learners or a review lesson may justify a different selection.
Keep a place for the material you leave out. A later lesson, an optional reference note or a follow-up question can preserve useful content without crowding the current practice. A clear takeaway gives you a way to decide what belongs now.
Hear Gav and Em discuss this
Hear Em make the case for a clear takeaway, followed by Gav’s reminder to start simply and avoid overloading learners.
Read the clip transcript
Em: There’s no use flogging a dead horse, I think the expression is. If the topic is done, move on. Don’t just try and get something out of it. But I will say, I think it’s very good if students get one very clear message or even one very clear grammar point or one very useful vocabulary word out of a lesson than hundreds of things they’re not gonna remember properly or maybe get a bit mixed up because there was so much going on.
Em: So it’s better they just get three, maybe maximum five really, really useful take phrases that they can use every day, correctly.
Gav: That’ll be my takeaway today. Have at least one key thing that you’re trying to teach in that lesson. Don’t overload the student. Start nice and simple. Glide into the lesson.
Teacher checklist
☐ State one useful learner action.
☐ Keep the explanation and language selection relevant to that action.
☐ Give learners a meaningful first attempt.
☐ Use feedback and a second attempt before adding more content.
☐ Check what each learner can do and plan the next step from that.
Plan the takeaway with TE1. Use the one-page planner to work back from the learner’s final task and leave room for feedback.